We were asked by Boost Kids to evaluate their program dedicated to helping kids learn self-esteem and social skills. The program consists of a cd-rom, workbook, and parents guide and is aimed at children ages 8-15.
Due to our different perspectives on this one, we decided to break it into 3 parts.
Jennifer said-
I haven’t always been an over-educated stay at home Mom. In fact, I used to earn a paycheck for working with kids! As a Speech-Language Pathologist, I worked with children who had communication disorders. Many of the lesson covered by the Boost Kids program were things that I targeted in my students’ therapy sessions.
One of the first things I noticed about the materials was that they were not very eye-catching or colorful. It appeared that these materials were targeted for adolescents to preteens. However, the subject matter seemed more suited for younger kids. The accompanying lessons presented on the CD-ROM probably would not hold the attention of many kids. I found myself daydreaming and making grocery lists in my head while watching it.
Personally, I’m not a huge believer in teaching children communication skills through worksheets and non-interactive computer lessons. To truly learn and improve communication skills requires actual practice. I think these lessons could certainly be a good starting place when introducing these subjects. An interactive computer game would definitely be a bonus for kids.
Heather said-
As a mom of a child with what some would call social difficulties, I was interested in the Boost Kids program. Unfortunately, my hopes for the program were short lived.
Call me a slacker mom but when a program starts off poo-pooing on technology such as instant and text messaging, and implying those advances are why it is more difficult to develop social skills, I’m immediately turned off. Hatin’ on modern communication technology will not earn any smiles from me. It’s the way of the future people and our arbitrary social rules will adapt to the social majority as they always have when times change. It has been my experience that instant message actually improves social relationships with friends and family, not the opposite. And while I did find one or two social lessons insightful, the majority of the lessons were ones that I believe children will pick up through modeling those adults around them. In my opinion, this product is not worth the $70 price tag.
Sara said-
I am so torn on this one! Unfortunately it seems the folks at Boost Kids had the same problem. When I heard it was a program to help with self esteem and social skills, I figured it would be perfect for a child my daughter’s age, kids around 7-9. However, they market this program to children ages 8-15. The problem with that is you don’t talk to an 8 year old in nearly the same way you would a 15 year old, and I think that’s where they got a little lost. Don’t get me wrong, the information in this program is solid- any help I can get teaching my kids things like proper telephone manners, making conversation, etc is greatly appreciated. But the skills they are teaching are things kids should know, or at least have begun learning, by ages 10-12, and is being presented with workbook and visuals that only a 12-15 year old could sit through. The workbook was a big turnoff, because there was very little in it that would appeal to kids. It was more like a test, and after being in school 7 hours a day, putting a workbook in front of my 9 year old would be pretty akin to punishment unless it had something to pull her in and keep her interested. As for the cd, again, not enough to hold the attention of a younger child, and too boring for an older child. I hate to recommend cartooney stuff, but I think Jennifer is right on the nose that making it into a computer game somehow would have given the user something to relate to and draw them in.
I think there are good lessons to be learned here, but they need to be repackaged in a way that is both more interesting, and possibly broken down into lessons for older kids and one for younger kids in order to more effectively reach their audience. In the meantime I’d seriously consider lowering the price point, because $69.95 is not only high for what you are getting here, but probably out of reach for the average everyday parent. Drop it to $29.95 and consider a redesign, and I think this could be a product worth saving 